Penalties taken by Messi vs Ronaldo against english teams

Penalty success rate

Lionel Messi

Cristiano Ronaldo

Penalty success rate in shootouts

Lionel Messi

Cristiano Ronaldo

Penalty success rate during the match

Lionel Messi

Cristiano Ronaldo

Success rate by team

Percentage of penalty goals with respect to the total goals scored

Lionel Messi

Cristiano Ronaldo

Percentage of penalty goals by team

Evolution of their success rate throughout the seasons

PeriodLionel MessiCristiano RonaldoDifference
2002/20030
2003/2004100.0000-100
2004/2005100.0000-100
2005/2006100.0000-100
2006/2007100.000083.3333+16.6667
2007/200885.714376.1905+9.5238
2008/200976.923182.1429-5.2198
2009/201081.250081.8182-0.5682
2010/201180.000085.7143-5.7143
2011/201279.545585.0000-5.4545
2012/201382.352985.2941-2.9412
2013/201482.812586.0759-3.2634
2014/201580.769285.4167-4.6475
2015/201677.272782.8829-5.6102
2016/201778.787982.1138-3.3259
2017/201876.635582.0896-5.4541
2018/201977.193082.2695-5.0765
2019/202077.686083.1250-5.439
2020/202177.777883.3333-5.5555
2021/202277.857182.8729-5.0158
2022/202378.807983.5979-4.79
2023/202478.431484.3902-5.9588
2024/202578.343984.0183-5.6744
2025/202677.300683.5498-6.2492
2026/202783.1897-83.1897

Cumulative distribution

PeriodLionel MessiCristiano RonaldoDifference
2003/2004000
2004/2005000
2005/200601-1
2006/200706-6
2007/2008011-11
2008/2009016-16
2009/2010016-16
2010/2011116-15
2011/2012116-15
2012/2013116-15
2013/2014216-14
2014/2015216-14
2015/2016316-13
2016/2017316-13
2017/2018317-14
2018/2019317-14
2021/2022320-17
2022/2023320-17

Distribution by season

PeriodLionel MessiCristiano RonaldoDifference
2003/20040
2004/20050
2005/20061-1
2006/20075-5
2007/20085-5
2008/20095-5
2009/20100
2010/20111+1
2011/20120
2012/20130
2013/20141+1
2014/20150
2015/20161+1
2016/20170
2017/20181-1
2018/20190
2021/20223-3
2022/20230

Distribution by season

PeriodLionel MessiCristiano RonaldoDifference
2003/20040
2004/20050
2005/20061-1
2006/20076-6
2007/20086-6
2008/20095-5
2009/20100
2010/20111+1
2011/20121+1
2012/20130
2013/20141+1
2014/20151+1
2015/20161+1
2016/20170
2017/20181-1
2018/20190
2021/20224-4
2022/20230

Every penalty taken by Messi and Ronaldo

Messi

Penalties in matches: 3 scored and 2 missed (60.0% conversion)

DateTeamOpponentCompetitionResultScoredMissed
23 Feb 2016FC BarcelonaArsenal FCUEFA Champions League · Round of 162-01
24 Feb 2015FC BarcelonaManchester City FCUEFA Champions League · Round of 162-11
18 Feb 2014FC BarcelonaManchester City FCUEFA Champions League · Round of 162-01
24 Apr 2012FC BarcelonaChelsea FCUEFA Champions League · Semifinals2-21
8 Mar 2011FC BarcelonaArsenal FCUEFA Champions League · Round of 163-11

Ronaldo

Penalties in matches: 20 scored and 3 missed (87.0% conversion)

DateTeamOpponentCompetitionResultScoredMissed
2 May 2022Manchester UtdBrentfordPremier League3-01
4 Feb 2022Manchester UtdMiddlesbrough FCFA Cup · Round of 321-11
11 Dec 2021Manchester UtdNorwich City FCPremier League1-01
2 Dec 2021Manchester UtdArsenal FCPremier League3-21
17 Oct 2017Real MadridTottenham Hotspur FCUEFA Champions League · Group stage1-11
25 Apr 2009Manchester UtdTottenham Hotspur FCPremier League5-21
14 Mar 2009Manchester UtdLiverpool FCPremier League1-41
31 Jan 2009Manchester UtdEverton FCPremier League1-01
20 Jan 2009Manchester UtdDerby County FCEFL Cup · Semifinals4-21
27 Sep 2008Manchester UtdBolton Wanderers FCPremier League2-01
11 May 2008Manchester UtdWigan Athletic FCPremier League2-01
13 Apr 2008Manchester UtdArsenal FCPremier League2-11
27 Jan 2008Manchester UtdTottenham Hotspur FCFA Cup · Round of 323-11
29 Dec 2007Manchester UtdWest Ham United FCPremier League1-21
23 Dec 2007Manchester UtdEverton FCPremier League2-11
8 Dec 2007Manchester UtdDerby County FCPremier League4-11
5 May 2007Manchester UtdManchester City FCPremier League1-01
19 Mar 2007Manchester UtdMiddlesbrough FCFA Cup · Quarter finals1-01
10 Mar 2007Manchester UtdMiddlesbrough FCFA Cup · Quarter finals2-21
4 Feb 2007Manchester UtdTottenham Hotspur FCPremier League4-01
31 Jan 2007Manchester UtdWatford FCPremier League4-01
26 Dec 2006Manchester UtdWigan Athletic FCPremier League3-11
30 Nov 2005Manchester UtdWest Bromwich Albion FCEFL Cup · Round of 163-11

Penalty shoot-outs: 2 scored and 1 missed (66.7% conversion)

DateTeamOpponentCompetitionResultScoredMissed
1 Mar 2009Manchester UtdTottenham Hotspur FCEFL Cup · Final0-01
21 May 2008Manchester UtdChelsea FCUEFA Champions League · Final1-11
21 May 2005Manchester UtdArsenal FCFA Cup · Final0-01

Penalties taken by Messi vs Ronaldo against english teams: key facts

Who has more goals without penalties?

Messi has scored 3 penalties and Ronaldo 20, which is 11.1% and 15.2% of their goals. Without penalties, Messi has 24 goals and Ronaldo 112, so Ronaldo is ahead by 88.

Data updated on 18/11/2026.

Cache date: 19-11-2026 15:38:17